Lite 99

Winter Springs commissioners approve first step in eminent domain bid for new wastewater plant

Winter Springs commissioners approve first step in eminent domain bid for new wastewater plant

 

Winter Springs city commissioners have approved the first step in using eminent domain to acquire 10 acres of land from the former Winter Springs Golf Club site to replace the aging West Water Reclamation Facility.

The city previously attempted to purchase the land but was unable to reach a deal with the property owner. Commissioners have now moved forward with eminent domain to secure the site.

The current wastewater plant has reached the end of its functional life and requires a full replacement to maintain reliable treatment service and meet future regulatory requirements. The planned facility would handle 1.6 million gallons per day, with provisions for future advanced wastewater treatment.

Three alternatives considered

City officials evaluated three approaches to site development, each carrying its own trade-offs in cost, complexity and community impact.

Alternative 1 would confine construction entirely within the existing facility’s footprint. While it avoids acquiring new property, the approach carries the highest construction and operational risk due to limited space, extensive project phasing and a heavy reliance on temporary facilities. Estimated at $72.8 million, it also carries the highest price tag and would take approximately 47 months to complete — the longest timeline of the three options.

[WATCH: Winter Springs boil water precaution advisory could last through Saturday]

Alternative 2 calls for acquiring roughly 3 acres of adjacent property, allowing some stormwater storage needs to shift off the main site. The approach reduces some complexity compared to Alternative 1, but many integration and sequencing challenges remain. Total cost is estimated at $73.1 million, including environmental mitigation, with a projected timeline of 35 months.

Alternative 3 takes the broadest approach, acquiring approximately 10 acres of adjacent land. That additional footprint allows the majority of new construction to take place away from the operational plant, dramatically reducing construction risk and scheduling complexity. It carries the shortest projected timeline at 29 months and the lowest overall cost at $66.6 million, including mitigation.

Recommended option

Despite its larger environmental footprint, Alternative 3 emerged as the recommended choice. Engineers and city planners concluded that its combination of lowest overall risk, lowest total cost and shortest schedule — paired with the strongest support for the city’s long-term wastewater needs — outweighs the higher upfront environmental mitigation requirements.

Eminent domain as last resort

Commissioner Victoria Bruce said Winter Springs previously tried and failed to purchase land from the property owner, making eminent domain the city’s best remaining option.

“A purchase would have had to occur, which was outrageous, the amount the landowner wanted to get to be able obtain 10 to 20 acres,” Bruce said. “This is the best course of action. I’ve been advocating for eminent domain since I got into office in 2022.”

=

You cannot copy content of this page. Code, Logo, and graphics are copyright Palm Tree Media.